Saturday, November 16, 2019

Impossible or Magic Coconut Pie

I decided to try the pie. The recipe is on the internet under Magic or Impossible and Bisquick.

I had the temperature as 400 degrees for 25 to 30 min. Well, it was not done - very soupy. I lowered the temp and left it in another 10 minutes.

Later I rechecked the recipe and it listed 350 degrees for 55 minutes. I had written the recipe and instructions some time ago. I don't know where I saw the 400 degrees but I remember at the time I thought that was pretty high.

Even with the error, the coconut was browned and not burned!


  1. It sure look good. I'm glad that even with the error it turned out well. I've done that before too and my MIL thinks everything should be cooked at 425, no matter what it is. Hubby says he never had a cookie as a child that wasn't black on the bottom. In fact, he says that until we got married, that's how he thought they were supposed to be! :-)

  2. We make an Impossible Cheeseburger pie...but use Italian Sausage instead...we like it! I love coconut so your pie sounds delish!